After decades of anticipation, Asheville residents are left reeling as Costco abruptly pulls the plug on its highly anticipated store plans. This shocking decision has left many wondering: What went wrong? And could this have been prevented?
In a recent email to City Council members, Asheville City Manager DK Wesley revealed that Costco cited escalating costs and project complexities as the primary reasons for withdrawing their application. These challenges, which included both on-site and off-site improvements, reportedly expanded the project’s scope, timeline, and budget beyond what was initially feasible. The city was officially notified of the withdrawal on Wednesday, with the proposed Enka Commerce Park site now left in limbo.
But here’s where it gets controversial: While Wesley noted that such withdrawals are not uncommon in large-scale projects, Asheville Mayor Esther Manheimer described the decision as a devastating blow to the city. “It’s a tragedy,” she stated, expressing deep disappointment and vowing to address any lingering challenges. Her emotional response underscores the community’s high hopes for the project, which promised to provide a much-needed retail option for locals who currently travel to Spartanburg or Greenville, South Carolina, to shop at the nearest Costco.
Councilmember Sage Turner echoed this sentiment, calling the withdrawal “disappointing news for our residents and the greater region.” Turner highlighted the overwhelming community support for the project, adding, “I’ll be following up with Costco’s team to learn more.” This raises the question: Could better communication or negotiation have saved the deal? Or was this an inevitable outcome given the project’s complexities?
Costco’s journey to Asheville has been a long one, with the retailer searching for a suitable Buncombe location for decades. Last year, the company submitted an ambitious application for a 25-acre store with 839 parking spaces within Enka Commerce Park. However, this required a conditional zoning amendment from the city, adding another layer of complexity to an already challenging project. And this is the part most people miss: While the city’s review process may not have been the direct cause of the withdrawal, it’s clear that the project’s scale and associated hurdles proved insurmountable for Costco.
As the dust settles, one thing is certain: Asheville’s Costco dream is on hold—for now. But the bigger question remains: What does this mean for future large-scale developments in the city? Are we prepared to handle the challenges that come with such projects, or will this become a cautionary tale for developers? What do you think? Is this a missed opportunity, or a necessary setback? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
[Editor’s note: This story will be updated as more information becomes available.]
Asheville Watchdog invites you to join the conversation on our Facebook page (http://facebook.com/avlwatchdog). As a nonprofit news team dedicated to producing stories that matter to Asheville and Buncombe County, we rely on your support. For more information, visit avlwatchdog.org/support-our-publication/. John Boyle, who has been covering Asheville since the 20th century, can be reached at (828) 337-0941 or jboyle@avlwatchdog.org.
